Meet Our Team

Meet the people behind Nulty Insurance.

Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team

Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Nulty Insurance, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most in business and in life.

Support Team

Stella

Chief Fetch Officer

Adam Burke

Director of Marketing

269-488-0349

Sandy Byers

Manager of Incoming Attitudes

269-488-0355

Sally Drobny

Director of Finance

269-488-0312

Julie Klok

Network Manager

269-488-0303

Gina Chimner

Manager of Incoming Attitudes

269-488-0330

Cheryl Jordan

Administrative Assistant

269-488-0302

Alexis Miller

Manager of Incoming Attitudes

269-694-9446

Business Insurance Team

Chad Bonner

Business Risk Advisor

269-488-0328

Sue Davidson

Account Executive

269-488-0313

Michele Hills

Account Executive

269-488-0353

Carol Howes

Account Executive

269-488-0320

Tom Jager

Team Leader / Business Risk Advisor

269-488-0317

Ben Miller

Small Business Division Advisor

269-488-0335

TG Nulty

President / Business Risk Advisor

269-488-0337

Janet Short

Marketing Manager

269-488-0325

Caitlan Stangl

Client Relationship Specialist

269-488-0311

Michael Stangl

Business Risk Advisor

269-488-0347

Angie Trepanier

Account Executive

269-488-0338

Kelley Watson

Business Risk Advisor

269-488-0310

Kristi Wright

Account Executive

269-488-0316

Employee Benefits Team

Stacey Bornamann

Account Support Manager

269-488-0336

Ted Chase

Employee Benefits Advisor

269-695-1851

Susan Culhane

Employee Benefits Department Manager

269-488-0322

Dawn Freeland

Individual Health, Life, and Small Group Advisor

269-488-0306

Jessica Holcomb

Market Solution Specialist

269-488-0304

Michelle Hostutler

Medicare Sales Advisor

269-488-0324

Carrie Nicholson

HR & Benefits Compliance Advisor

269-488-0354

Kelly Olmsted

Benefits Analyst

269-488-0319

Chip Schelb

Employee Benefits Advisor

269-488-0314

Tenneil Shaffer

Director of Market Solutions

269-488-0331

Sandy Vroegop

Account Executive

269-488-0305

Tina Wynn

Account Executive

269-695-1839

Personal Insurance Team

Cassie Austin

Account Manager

269-488-0348

Michele Bennett

Account Manager

269-488-0329

Bruce Bodfish

Personal Insurance Advisor

269-488-0301

Dave Breithaupt

Personal Insurance Advisor

269-488-0308

Shelly Brush

Account Manager

269-488-0344

Anmarie Chandler

Account Manager

269-488-0323

Michelle Cook

Account Manager

269-488-0327

Kelli Drobny

Interface Agent

269-488-0342

Amber Henrickson

Account Manager

269-488-0340

Jennifer Johnson

Account Manager

269-488-0346

Ann Kuiper

Personal Lines Department Manager

269-488-0315

Melissa Lange

Account Manager

269-488-0343

Jacob Larkin

Account Manager

269-488-0357

Stacy Moore

Account Manager

269-488-0334

Bill Shearer

Personal Insurance Advisor

269-488-0341

Nulty Insurance is an independent insurance agency made up of exceptional, passionate people focused on protecting you from the unexpected.

Insurance Quote Request

As an independent agency, we offer multiple options at competitive prices.


  • Coverage will not be bound or changed until confirmed by a licensed agent.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.